Skip to content
Nutrition & metabolismRandomised trial4 min read

Severe dieting cost no extra relative lean mass in obese postmenopausal women but cost hip bone

MoveVitals Editorial Collective · Study published · Reading updated

Original paper:Effect of Weight Loss via Severe vs Moderate Energy Restriction on Lean Mass and Body Composition Among Postmenopausal Women With Obesity: The TEMPO Diet Randomized Clinical Trial. · JAMA network open · 2019 · Original paper ↗

Key takeaway

In a 12-month trial of 101 postmenopausal women with obesity, severe energy restriction led to 6.6 kg more weight loss than moderate restriction, with lean mass loss proportional to weight lost, but also greater loss of total hip bone mineral density. It was a single-centre trial in Sydney, so caution is needed in generalising.

Study design

Randomised trial

Reading basis

Published abstract

Reading focus

Comparator & uncertainty

The research question

Severely energy-restricted diets are the most effective dietary treatment for obesity, but there are worries that they strip muscle and harm body composition. The authors compared the long-term effects of severe versus moderate energy restriction on lean mass and other aspects of body composition in postmenopausal women.

Who and how

The TEMPO Diet Trial was a 12-month, single-centre randomized clinical trial of 101 postmenopausal women aged 45 to 65 with body mass index 30 to 40, at least 5 years past menopause, doing fewer than 3 hours of structured activity per week, in Sydney, Australia (recruited March 2013 to July 2016). One group followed moderate (25%-35%) energy restriction with a food-based diet for 12 months. The other had 4 months of severe (65%-75%) restriction with total meal replacement, then moderate restriction for 8 months. Both had a prescribed protein intake of 1.0 g/kg of actual body weight per day, and exercise was encouraged but unsupervised. The primary outcome was whole-body lean mass at 12 months, with secondary outcomes measured at 0, 4, 6 and 12 months.

What it found

The authors’ reported results. Read each estimate with its population and uncertainty.

  1. 1
    At 12 months the severe group lost more weight than the moderate group (effect size -6.6 kg; 95% CI -8.2 to -5.1) and more whole-body fat mass (-5.5 kg; 95% CI -7.1 to -3.9).
  2. 2
    The severe group lost more whole-body lean mass (-1.2 kg; 95% CI -2.0 to -0.4) and thigh muscle area (-4.2 cm2; 95% CI -6.5 to -1.9). These losses were proportional to total weight loss, and handgrip strength did not differ between groups.
  3. 3
    Total hip bone mineral density fell more in the severe group (-0.017 g/cm2; 95% CI -0.029 to -0.005).
  4. 4
    Abdominal subcutaneous fat (-1890 cm3; 95% CI -2560 to -1219) and visceral fat (-1389 cm3; 95% CI -1748 to -1030) fell more in the severe group. The authors summarise a 2-fold greater weight and fat loss.

Limits & uncertainty

  1. 1
    Only women aged 45 to 65 with obesity and little structured activity were enrolled in one city, so results may not apply to men, younger women or very active people.
  2. 2
    Exercise was encouraged but not supervised, and protein intake was prescribed rather than monitored in the abstract, so these may have shaped lean mass results.
  3. 3
    The primary outcome was lean mass, and the bone, strength and fat findings were secondary outcomes, so they carry less certainty.
  4. 4
    This reading is based on the abstract only.

What to take from it

Losing weight fast through severe calorie restriction did not cost proportionally more muscle or grip strength, but it did cost more hip bone density. This is a reason for caution, especially for women with osteopenia or osteoporosis, who should discuss any very-low-energy diet with their clinician first. It does not show that one diet is better overall.

Reading your own data

Weigh in at the same time of day on the same scale and watch weekly trends. Body-fat percentages from home scales are estimates, so do not treat small changes as real muscle or fat change. Bone density cannot be tracked at home and needs a clinical scan.

How to read this evidence

Randomisation can support causal inference, but check allocation, blinding, missing outcomes, follow-up and the actual comparator. A trial label alone does not establish high certainty.

Authors’ structured abstract English

The attributed English abstract is reproduced under the recorded open licence. It is source material, not a MoveVitals interpretation. The prepared analysis above separates the authors’ findings from our interpretation.

Importance

Severely energy-restricted diets are the most effective dietary obesity treatment. However, there are concerns regarding potential adverse effects on body composition.

Objective

To compare the long-term effects of weight loss via severe vs moderate energy restriction on lean mass and other aspects of body composition.

Design, setting, and participants

The Type of Energy Manipulation for Promoting Optimum Metabolic Health and Body Composition in Obesity (TEMPO) Diet Trial was a 12-month, single-center, randomized clinical trial. A total of 101 postmenopausal women, aged 45 to 65 years with body mass index (calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared) from 30 to 40, who were at least 5 years after menopause, had fewer than 3 hours of structured physical activity per week, and lived in the Sydney metropolitan area of New South Wales, Australia, were recruited between March 2013 and July 2016. Data analysis was conducted between October 2018 and August 2019.

Intervention

Participants were randomized to either 12 months of moderate (25%-35%) energy restriction with a food-based diet (moderate intervention) or 4 months of severe (65%-75%) energy restriction with a total meal replacement diet followed by moderate energy restriction for an additional 8 months (severe intervention). Both interventions had a prescribed protein intake of 1.0 g/kg of actual body weight per day, and physical activity was encouraged but not supervised.

Main outcomes and measures

The primary outcome was whole-body lean mass at 12 months after commencement of intervention. Secondary outcomes were body weight, thigh muscle area and muscle function (strength), bone mineral density, and fat mass and distribution, measured at 0, 4, 6, and 12 months.

Results

A total of 101 postmenopausal women were recruited (mean [SD] age, 58.0 [4.2] years; mean [SD] weight, 90.8 [9.1] kg; mean [SD] body mass index, 34.4 [2.5]). Compared with the moderate group at 12 months, the severe group lost more weight (effect size, -6.6 kg; 95% CI, -8.2 to -5.1 kg), lost more whole-body lean mass (effect size, -1.2 kg; 95% CI, -2.0 to -0.4 kg), and lost more thigh muscle area (effect size, -4.2 cm2; 95% CI, -6.5 to -1.9 cm2). However, decreases in whole-body lean mass and thigh muscle area were proportional to total weight loss, and there was no difference in muscle (handgrip) strength between groups. Total hip bone mineral density (effect size, -0.017 g/cm2; 95% CI, -0.029 to -0.005 g/cm2), whole-body fat mass (effect size, -5.5 kg; 95% CI, -7.1 to -3.9 kg), abdominal subcutaneous adipose tissue (effect size, -1890 cm3; 95% CI, -2560 to -1219 cm3), and visceral adipose tissue (effect size, -1389 cm3; 95% CI, -1748 to -1030 cm3) loss were also greater for the severe group than for the moderate group at 12 months.

Conclusions and relevance

Severe energy restriction had no greater adverse effect on relative whole-body lean mass or handgrip strength compared with moderate energy restriction and was associated with 2-fold greater weight and fat loss over 12 months. However, there was significantly greater loss of total hip bone mineral density with severe vs moderate energy restriction. Therefore, caution is necessary when implementing severe energy restriction in postmenopausal women, particularly those with osteopenia or osteoporosis.

Trial registration

anzctr.org.au Identifier: 12612000651886.

Sources & attribution

Effect of Weight Loss via Severe vs Moderate Energy Restriction on Lean Mass and Body Composition Among Postmenopausal Women With Obesity: The TEMPO Diet Randomized Clinical Trial.

Seimon RV, Wild-Taylor AL, Keating SE, McClintock S, Harper C, Gibson AA, Johnson NA, Fernando HA, Markovic TP, Center JR, Franklin J, Liu PY, Grieve SM, Lagopoulos J, Caterson ID, Byrne NM, Sainsbury A.

JAMA network open · 2019-10-02

DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.13733 ↗PubMed · 31664441 ↗Europe PMC · Recorded licence: cc by ↗

Abstract © the original authors, reproduced under the recorded open licence. Translations support reading; use the English record to check terminology and numerical results. Our methodological interpretation is separate from the authors’ conclusions.

MoveVitals editorial interpretation · educational content · no individual clinical review recorded

Sources checked 2026-11-01

Practical guides

Read in context

·Trial meta-analysis

Early time-restricted eating linked to more weight loss and lower insulin than late eating

Pooling 41 randomised trials (2287 participants, median intervention 8 weeks), time-restricted eating was associated with 2.15 kg lower body weight than usual diets (95% CI -2.56 to -1.74), and eating early beat eating late by 1.15 kg (95% CI -1.86 to -0.45). Most trials were short, only 6 study arms tested early eating, and the outcomes were body and blood measures, not heart attacks or deaths.

BMJ Medicine

In-depth explainersRead study →
·Randomised trial

An 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. eating window added to calorie cutting gave no clear extra weight loss

Among 139 patients with obesity on a calorie-restricted diet, adding an eating window of 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. led to a mean 12-month weight change of -8.0 kg, versus -6.3 kg with calorie restriction alone. The net difference of -1.8 kg (95% CI -4.0 to 0.4; P = 0.11) was not statistically significant, and the interval cannot rule out either a real benefit or none.

The New England Journal of Medicine

In-depth explainersRead study →
·Randomised trial

In a 20-person ward trial, an ultra-processed menu led to more eating and weight gain

In 20 adults living in a hospital research unit for 28 days, an ultra-processed menu led them to eat 508 kcal/day more (± 106 SE, P = 0.0001) and gain 0.9 kg, while a menu of unprocessed foods led to a 0.9 kg loss, each over 2 weeks and with eating left to appetite. The study was small, short and fully provisioned, so it cannot show what happens in daily life or which feature of the foods drove the extra eating.

Cell Metabolism

In-depth explainersRead study →
·Randomised trial

Mediterranean diet with olive oil or nuts linked to fewer heart events (corrected trial)

Among 7447 Spanish adults aged 55 to 80 at high cardiovascular risk, those assigned to a Mediterranean diet with extra-virgin olive oil (HR 0.69, 95% CI 0.53 to 0.91) or with nuts (HR 0.72, 0.54 to 0.95) had fewer major cardiovascular events than those told to cut dietary fat. The trial had randomisation errors, which is why the 2013 report was withdrawn and the estimates recalculated, so treat this as strong but imperfect evidence.

The New England Journal of Medicine

In-depth explainersRead study →
Nutrition & metabolism →