Key takeaway
In a 6-month trial of 160 obese, mildly to moderately frail adults aged 65 or older, a weight-loss programme plus combined aerobic and resistance exercise raised the Physical Performance Test score by 5.5 points, against 3.9 points for either exercise type alone and 1.0 for controls. Every exercise group still lost lean mass, and all but the resistance group lost hip bone density, so the combined programme softened these losses rather than preventing them. The volunteers were screened, trained under supervision and were mostly white, well-educated women.
Study design
Randomised trial
Reading basis
Full text
Reading focus
Comparator & uncertainty
The research question
More than a third of people aged 65 or older in the United States are obese, and obesity speeds the age-related decline in physical function and can cause frailty. Whether older adults should lose weight is still debated, partly because a higher body-mass index has been linked to lower relative health risk in this age group, and partly because dieting could accelerate the loss of muscle and bone (sarcopenia and osteopenia) and make frailty worse. The same team had earlier found that diet plus combined aerobic and resistance exercise improved function more than diet alone or exercise alone, but exercise only softened the loss of muscle and bone and eased frailty without reversing it. Aerobic training builds cardiovascular fitness and resistance training builds strength, and the two sets of adaptations might interfere with each other when trained together. The Lifestyle Intervention Trial in Obese Elderly (LITOE) therefore compared diet plus aerobic, resistance or combined exercise head to head, with the hypothesis that resistance exercise would improve function most.
Who and how
LITOE was a randomised, controlled trial run from April 2010 through June 2015 at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine and the New Mexico Veterans Affairs Health Care System, funded by the National Institutes of Health. Participants were recruited through advertisements and medically screened. They had to be 65 or older, obese (body-mass index of 30 or more), sedentary (regular exercise under 1 hour per week), weight-stable and medication-stable for 6 months, and mildly to moderately frail (a score of 18 to 31 on the 0 to 36 modified Physical Performance Test). People with severe cardiopulmonary disease, conditions that prevented training, cognitive impairment or bone-active drugs were excluded. Of 160 people randomised (40 per group, stratified by sex; average age 70, 60% to 70% women in each group), 141 (88%) finished. The control group received no weight-management or exercise programme, only monthly group sessions on healthy eating. The other three groups shared one weight-management programme: a daily energy deficit of 500 to 750 kcal, about 1 g of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, weekly dietitian visits and a goal of roughly 10% weight loss at 6 months. Each added supervised exercise three times a week: aerobic (walking, cycling, stair climbing at about 65% of peak heart rate, rising to 70 to 85%), resistance (nine weight-machine exercises, from 1 to 2 sets of 8 to 12 repetitions at 65% of the one-repetition maximum up to 2 to 3 sets at about 85%) or both, in longer sessions of 75 to 90 minutes built to match the aerobic dose of the aerobic group and the resistance dose of the resistance group. Everyone also received calcium (about 1500 mg) and vitamin D (about 1000 IU) daily.
The primary outcome was the 6-month change in the Physical Performance Test, which times and scores standardised daily tasks such as walking 15.2 m, standing from a chair and climbing stairs. Secondary outcomes were peak oxygen consumption on a graded treadmill walk, the Functional Status Questionnaire, strength (the heaviest weight lifted once, totalled across six lifts), balance, fast gait speed over 7.6 m, fat and lean mass and bone mineral density from dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (same scanner at baseline and follow-up), thigh muscle by magnetic resonance imaging, and quality of life on the SF-36 survey. Assessors did not know the group assignments. The analysis followed intention-to-treat, including the 19 people who stopped the intervention, using mixed-model repeated-measures analysis of variance adjusted for baseline values and sex. The primary outcome used five prespecified comparisons with Bonferroni correction, and secondary outcomes were tested only after a gatekeeping rule on the primary result was met. Multiple imputation for missing fitness data served as a sensitivity check. The sample size of 40 per group gave 80% power to detect a 1.8-point difference on the Physical Performance Test.
What it found
- 1Adding both kinds of exercise to a weight-loss programme improved overall physical function more than either kind alone. On the Physical Performance Test (the primary outcome) the combination group rose 5.5±0.4 points (27.9 to 33.4, a 21% increase), against 3.9±0.4 points in the aerobic group (29.3 to 33.2, 14%) and 3.9±0.4 points in the resistance group (28.8 to 32.7, 14%); the differences were P=0.01 against aerobic and P=0.02 against resistance after Bonferroni correction. All three exercise groups beat the control group, whose score rose 1.0±0.4 points (4%) (P<0.001 for between-group comparisons), while the aerobic and resistance groups did not differ from each other (P=0.87 in the paper's table).
- 2Each exercise type built its own fitness quality, and the combination group kept both instead of trading one off. Peak oxygen consumption (millilitres per kilogram per minute) rose 3.1±0.3 in the combination group (17.2 to 20.3, 17%) and 3.3±0.3 in the aerobic group (17.6 to 20.9, 18%), versus 1.3±0.3 in the resistance group (17.0 to 18.3, 8%) (P<0.001 for both comparisons). Total one-repetition maximum strength rose 48±5 kg in the combination group (272 to 320 kg, 18%) and 49±5 kg in the resistance group (288 to 337 kg, 19%), versus 5±5 kg in the aerobic group (265 to 270 kg, 4%) (P<0.001 for both comparisons). The authors had raised the possibility that the two training types would interfere with each other and saw no sign of it.
- 3Weight loss was the same across exercise groups, but muscle loss was not. Body weight fell by 9.0±0.6 kg with aerobic, 8.5±0.5 kg with resistance and 8.5±0.5 kg with combination training (each 9%), against 0.9±0.5 kg in controls, who did not change significantly; fat mass fell 6.3±0.5, 7.3±0.4 and 7.0±0.5 kg. Lean mass fell least with resistance training (1.0±0.3 kg, 58.1 to 57.1 kg, 2%), then combination (1.7±0.3 kg, 56.5 to 54.8 kg, 3%) and most with aerobic training (2.7±0.3 kg, 55.0 to 52.3 kg, 5%); combination versus aerobic was P=0.047 and combination versus resistance P=0.20. So exercise reduced, but did not prevent, the loss of lean mass.
- 4Only resistance training protected hip bone density. Total-hip bone mineral density did not change significantly with resistance training (1.047 to 1.041 g per square centimetre, a change of 0.006±0.004, under 1%), but fell with aerobic training (1.018 to 0.991, 0.027±0.004, 2.6%) and combination training (1.010 to 0.996, 0.014±0.004, 1.1%); the combination group's loss was smaller than the aerobic group's (P=0.04). Whole-body and lumbar-spine bone mineral density did not change significantly in any group.
- 5The combination group also improved most on everyday-function measures. The Functional Status Questionnaire (0 to 36) rose 3.6±0.3 points, versus 2.0±0.3 with aerobic and 2.3±0.3 with resistance training. Fast gait speed rose 12.1±1.3 metres per minute (68.8 to 80.9) against 8.1±1.3 with aerobic, and obstacle-course time fell 2.9±0.3 seconds (17.0 to 14.1) against 1.5±0.4; against the resistance group the gaps in gait speed and obstacle-course time were not significant (P=0.09 and P=0.20). The SF-36 physical-component score rose 9.5±0.7 points, versus 6.5±0.7 with aerobic and 7.4±0.8 with resistance training.
- 6Adherence was high and the harms were mostly musculoskeletal. Median attendance at exercise sessions was 96% in the aerobic group, 98% in the resistance group and 93% in the combination group, and 141 of 160 participants (88%) completed the trial. Exercise-related adverse events included falling, shoulder pain and back pain in the aerobic group; atrial fibrillation, shoulder pain and knee pain in the resistance group; and shoulder injury, knee, back and hip pain in the combination group.
Limits & uncertainty
- 1The authors note that the exclusion criteria left participants who were physically able to take part in a lifestyle programme, so they may not represent the wider population of obese older adults. Most were women, white and well educated, which limits generalisation to other groups.
- 2The authors note the sample was not large enough to compare results by sex, so it is unknown whether men and women respond differently to the three programmes.
- 3The authors note that a 6-month efficacy trial cannot show whether weight loss plus combined training prolongs independent living, and that it is unclear whether better function lowers the risk of falls and fractures despite the fall in hip bone density. (Our observation: falls and fractures were not among the reported outcomes.)
- 4Our observation: every exercise arm also dieted, and the control arm had neither diet nor exercise, so the trial cannot separate what the diet did from what exercise added. The combination sessions also ran 75 to 90 minutes against about 60 for the single-mode sessions; this was deliberate, to preserve each component's dose, but it means the winning group also trained longest.
- 5Our observation: sessions were supervised by trainers with median attendance of 93% to 98%, and 19 participants stopped the intervention before 6 months; unsupervised older adults may adhere less well, and the missing 6-month data were handled by intention-to-treat analysis with a multiple-imputation check only for fitness data.
What to take from it
For an older adult with obesity and some frailty, this trial supports pairing a reduced-calorie diet with both endurance and strength training rather than picking one. The combined routine gave the largest gain on a standard function test, kept the fitness gain of aerobic work and the strength gain of lifting, and softened the muscle and bone losses that come with dieting. These were medically screened, supervised sessions of roughly 60 to 90 minutes three times a week, with protein at about 1 g per kilogram per day plus calcium and vitamin D, so diet and supplements are part of the programme and are best set with a clinician or dietitian.
The trial does not show that dieting is safe or advisable for every older person, that exercise prevents muscle and bone loss during weight loss (it reduced them), or that higher test scores mean fewer falls or fractures or longer independence; none of these was measured. Injuries occurred, so people with heart disease, joint problems or marked frailty should plan any programme with their own clinician. Confidence is good for the 6-month function results of a randomised trial with blinded assessors and low for long-term outcomes.
Reading your own data
Log your weekly sessions, your heart rate during aerobic work (the trial started at about 65% of peak heart rate and built to 70 to 85%) and a weekly average of body weight rather than single daily readings. Treat a watch's VO2max estimate as a model output, not the treadmill test used here, and compare it only with your own earlier values on the same device. For strength, keep a lift log (exercise, load, sets, repetitions) and repeat the same timed walk over a fixed distance every few weeks; home body-fat or lean-mass readings are not scans and are poor evidence of muscle loss.
How to read this evidence
Randomisation can support causal inference, but check allocation, blinding, missing outcomes, follow-up and the actual comparator. A trial label alone does not establish high certainty.
Sources & attribution
Aerobic or Resistance Exercise, or Both, in Dieting Obese Older Adults
The New England Journal of Medicine · 2017-05-18
DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1616338 ↗PubMed · 28514618 ↗MoveVitals editorial interpretation · educational content · no individual clinical review recorded
Sources checked 2026-11-01
Practical guides
Read in context
ACSM review of 137 reviews: resistance training works, and few programme details matter
The American College of Sports Medicine pooled 137 systematic reviews (over 30,000 healthy adults) and concluded that resistance training beats no exercise for strength, muscle size, power, endurance and several function tests. Few programme details changed results consistently: heavier loads (80% or more of one-repetition maximum) and 2 to 3 sets favoured strength, and at least 10 sets a week favoured muscle size, while training to failure, exercise type and periodization did not. It summarises reviews rather than new trials, gives no pooled effect sizes, and drew mostly on untrained adults and overlapping source trials.
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Nearly every resistance training plan beat no exercise; heavy loads led for strength
In a network meta-analysis of randomised trials in healthy adults (178 studies and 5097 people for strength, 119 studies and 3364 people for muscle size), nearly all resistance training prescriptions beat no exercise. Higher-load, multiset, thrice-weekly training ranked best for strength (standardised mean difference 1.60, 95% credible interval 1.38 to 1.82) and higher-load, multiset, twice-weekly training for muscle size (0.66, 0.47 to 0.85). Most prescriptions could not be statistically separated from each other (the 95% interval contained zero in 91% of the comparisons between them) and risk of bias was moderate to high, so the rankings are tentative.
British Journal of Sports Medicine
Muscle-strengthening linked to lower risk of death, heart disease, cancer and diabetes
Pooling 16 prospective cohort studies of adults, people who did muscle-strengthening activity had a 15% lower risk of all-cause mortality (RR 0.85, 95% CI 0.79 to 0.93) and a 17% lower risk of both cardiovascular disease and diabetes (RR 0.83 for each) than people who did none. The pooled mortality curve was lowest at about 40 min/week (RR 0.83), but whether larger amounts help or hurt is unclear. All of this is observational, from mostly US self-reported data, and the authors rated the certainty of evidence as very low for most outcomes.
British Journal of Sports Medicine
Protein supplements and weight training: small extra gains, smaller in older adults
Pooling 49 randomised trials with 1,863 healthy adults who did resistance training for at least 6 weeks, protein supplements added 0.30 kg of fat-free mass (95% CI 0.09 to 0.52) and 2.49 kg of one-repetition-maximum strength (0.64 to 4.33) on top of training alone. These gains were small next to the effect of training itself, were weaker with older age, and the suggested plateau near 1.6 g/kg/day was not statistically significant (p=0.079). One author has received funding from the US National Dairy Council, which supported trials in the analysis.
British Journal of Sports Medicine

