跳到正文
營養與代謝研究論文3 分鐘閱讀

7款熱門飲食記錄App:好用、熱量較準,蛋白質和脂肪偏差更大

MoveVitals 編輯部 · 研究發表 · 解讀更新

原文:A Focused Review of Smartphone Diet-Tracking Apps: Usability, Functionality, Coherence With Behavior Change Theory, and Comparative Validity of Nutrient Intake and Energy Estimates. · JMIR mHealth and uHealth · 2019 · 論文原文 ↗

先看重點

在7款排名靠前的飲食記錄App中,系統可用性量表得分從46.7到89.2不等;用各App記錄同一份3天飲食日記,與美國農業部參考值相比,熱量平均相差1.4%,蛋白質相差10.4%,脂肪相差-6.5%。該比較只基於一份估算的3天日記和7款App,不能說明App在日常多樣飲食中的真實準確度。

證據類型

研究論文

解讀依據

公開摘要

閱讀重點

方法與適用範圍

研究在問什麼

很多人用手機App記錄飲食,希望減重或管理慢性病,但這些App好不好用、營養資料與權威資料庫是否一致,此前研究很少。作者比較了iOS和安卓上最熱門的飲食App:可用性如何、功能涵蓋哪些行為改變技術,以及營養素數值與美國農業部參考資料的吻合程度。

研究對象與方法

App評測加營養素比對。從iOS和安卓應用商店各選出排名靠前的7款飲食記錄App,使用2週。研究者分別用系統可用性量表(SUS)打分,並把App功能對照行為改變理論「理論領域框架」進行歸類。每款App都錄入同一份估算的3天飲食日記,並將這些食物與美國農業部(USDA)食物成分資料庫的參考值比較。摘要未說明由幾位研究者打分,也未說明日記中食物的選擇方式。

主要發現

以下為作者報告的結果。數值須連同族群和不確定性一起閱讀。

  1. 1
    可用性差異很大:LifeSum的SUS得分最高(89.2),MyDietCoach最低(46.7)。同一款App的安卓版和iOS版功能有些不同,主要是MyDietCoach,這影響了它的得分。
  2. 2
    所有App都具備「能力信念」領域的功能,也就是能幫助人們增強記錄飲食、跟進目標的信心。但沒有一款App能記錄與飲食模式相關的情緒因素。
  3. 3
    行為改變功能越多,可用性只呈較弱的相關(R²為0到.396);「強化」類功能是例外,與較低的可用性相關。
  4. 4
    與USDA參考值相比,各App的平均差異為:熱量1.4%,碳水化合物1.0%,蛋白質10.4%,脂肪-6.5%。

限制與不確定性

  1. 1
    只評測了從應用商店排名中選出的7款App,結果不能代表其他眾多飲食App。
  2. 2
    準確性檢驗只用了一份估算的3天日記,而不是許多人的真實記錄,無法說明不同食物、份量或餐館菜餚下誤差如何變化。
  3. 3
    摘要只給出平均差異,沒有給出各App之間或各天之間的離散程度,單個App的誤差可能比平均值更大。
  4. 4
    本解讀僅基於摘要。

日常健康啟示

這些熱門App給出的熱量和碳水化合物與USDA參考值較接近,蛋白質和脂肪的估算則不夠穩定,可以當作大致參考。選App時,好用的介面有助於堅持記錄,但可用性得分高不等於資料準確。這項評測沒有檢驗使用這些App是否能改變體重或健康狀況。

如何連結自己的資料

如果你用App記錄飲食,建議固定使用同一款App和同樣的份量稱量方式,這樣自己前後幾天、幾週的趨勢才可比。熱量和碳水化合物的訊號相對更可靠,蛋白質和脂肪的數值宜當作近似值看待。

如何理解這類證據

索引未明確指出具體研究設計,應先讀方法;核對族群、對照、結果和不確定性,再判斷能否作因果解釋。

作者的結構化摘要 English

以下英文摘要依所記錄的開放授權轉載,屬於作者原始材料,並非 MoveVitals 解讀。上方已提供研究解讀,分別說明作者結果與本站解釋;重要結論可直接查核原文。

Background

Smartphone diet-tracking apps may help individuals lose weight, manage chronic conditions, and understand dietary patterns; however, the usabilities and functionalities of these apps have not been well studied.

Objective

The aim of this study was to review the usability of current iPhone operating system (iOS) and Android diet-tracking apps, the degree to which app features align with behavior change constructs, and to assess variations between apps in nutrient coding.

Methods

The top 7 diet-tracking apps were identified from the iOS iTunes and Android Play online stores, downloaded and used over a 2-week period. Each app was independently scored by researchers using the System Usability Scale (SUS), and features were compared with the domains in an integrated behavior change theory framework: the Theoretical Domains Framework. An estimated 3-day food diary was completed using each app, and food items were entered into the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Food Composition Databases to evaluate their differences in nutrient data against the USDA reference.

Results

Of the apps that were reviewed, LifeSum had the highest average SUS score of 89.2, whereas MyDietCoach had the lowest SUS score of 46.7. Some variations in features were noted between Android and iOS versions of the same apps, mainly for MyDietCoach, which affected the SUS score. App features varied considerably, yet all of the apps had features consistent with Beliefs about Capabilities and thus have the potential to promote self-efficacy by helping individuals track their diet and progress toward goals. None of the apps allowed for tracking of emotional factors that may be associated with diet patterns. The presence of behavior change domain features tended to be weakly correlated with greater usability, with R^(2) ranging from 0 to .396. The exception to this was features related to the Reinforcement domain, which were correlated with less usability. Comparing the apps with the USDA reference for a 3-day diet, the average differences were 1.4% for calories, 1.0% for carbohydrates, 10.4% for protein, and -6.5% for fat.

Conclusions

Almost all reviewed diet-tracking apps scored well with respect to usability, used a variety of behavior change constructs, and accurately coded calories and carbohydrates, allowing them to play a potential role in dietary intervention studies.

來源與署名

A Focused Review of Smartphone Diet-Tracking Apps: Usability, Functionality, Coherence With Behavior Change Theory, and Comparative Validity of Nutrient Intake and Energy Estimates.

Ferrara G, Kim J, Lin S, Hua J, Seto E.

JMIR mHealth and uHealth · 2019-05-17

DOI: 10.2196/mhealth.9232 ↗PubMed · 31102369 ↗Europe PMC · 所記錄的開放授權: cc by ↗

摘要著作權歸原作者,依來源紀錄的開放授權轉載。中文譯文協助閱讀,英文摘要供查核術語及具體數值;本站的方法學解釋與作者結論分別呈現。

MoveVitals 編輯解讀 · 健康教育內容 · 未記錄個人臨床審閱

來源查核日期 2026-11-01

實用健康指南

放在一起讀

·隨機試驗統合分析

更早的進食視窗與更大的體重和胰島素獲益相關,優於晚間進食

彙總41項隨機對照試驗(2287名參與者,介入時間中位數8週)發現,限時進食比日常飲食體重低2.15 kg(95%置信區間−2.56至−1.74),而早吃比晚吃體重多降1.15 kg(95%置信區間−1.86至−0.45)。多數試驗較短,只有6個研究組檢驗了早間進食,結局是身體和血液指標,不是心臟病發作或死亡。

BMJ Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·隨機對照試驗

限熱量飲食再加上午8點至下午4點進食視窗,1年減重無明顯額外優勢

139名肥胖患者都按限制熱量的飲食進食,其中一組再加上上午8:00至下午4:00的進食視窗,12個月平均體重變化為−8.0 kg,單純限熱量組為−6.3 kg。淨差值−1.8 kg(95%置信區間−4.0至0.4;P=0.11)無統計學意義,該區間既不能排除視窗確有獲益,也不能排除毫無作用。

The New England Journal of Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·隨機對照試驗

20人住院試驗:超加工飲食讓人每天多攝取508 kcal並增重

20名成年人在醫院研究病房住了28天,兩種選單各吃2週、想吃多少吃多少:超加工選單讓他們每天多攝取508 kcal(±106,標準誤,P=0.0001),體重增加0.9 kg;未加工選單則讓體重減輕0.9 kg。樣本小、週期短、食物全程由研究方提供,既不能說明日常生活中的長期結果,也無法確定是食物的哪種特點導致多吃。

Cell Metabolism

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·隨機對照試驗

地中海飲食加橄欖油或堅果與心血管事件減少相關(更正後的試驗)

在7447名55至80歲、心血管風險較高的西班牙成年人中,被分到加特級初榨橄欖油(風險比0.69,95%置信區間0.53至0.91)或加堅果(風險比0.72,0.54至0.95)的地中海飲食組,發生主要心血管事件的風險低於被告知減少脂肪的對照組。試驗存在隨機化失誤,2013年的報告已撤回並重新估算,證據有力但並不完美。

The New England Journal of Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
營養與代謝 →