跳到正文
營養與代謝研究論文4 分鐘閱讀

150多個國家的模型:低肉飲食減少死亡和排放,但各地並不相同

MoveVitals 編輯部 · 研究發表 · 解讀更新

原文:Health and nutritional aspects of sustainable diet strategies and their association with environmental impacts: a global modelling analysis with country-level detail. · The Lancet. Planetary health · 2018 · 論文原文 ↗

先看重點

在覆蓋150多個國家的模型中,能量平衡的低肉飲食估計可使過早死亡減少19%(95%置信區間18-20,彈性素食)至22%(18-24,純素食),溫室氣體排放減少54-87%。這些是模擬情景,不是實際觀察結果,在低收入國家部分資源使用還會增加。

證據類型

研究論文

解讀依據

公開摘要

閱讀重點

方法與適用範圍

研究在問什麼

許多飲食被認為是可持續的,但很少有研究在區域層面同時評估它們的營養、健康和環境影響。作者比較了三種思路:以環境目標、糧食安全目標和公共衛生目標為導向的飲食方案。

研究對象與方法

對150多個國家進行的全球建模分析,包含三組飲食情景。環境組把25-100%的動物源性食物替換為植物性食物;糧食安全組把體重過輕、超重和肥胖減少25-100%;公共衛生組採用四種能量平衡的飲食模式:彈性素食、魚素食、素食和純素食。營養分析依據國際推薦量計算營養素充足程度;死亡率變化透過對比風險評估估算,涉及9個與飲食和體重相關的危險因素;環境分析使用各國、各食物類別的足跡,涵蓋溫室氣體排放、耕地、淡水、氮肥和磷肥使用。研究由Wellcome Trust、EAT、CGIAR和英國心臟基金會資助。

主要發現

以下為作者報告的結果。數值須連同族群和不確定性一起閱讀。

  1. 1
    用植物性食物替代動物源性食物在高收入國家效果最好:完全替代時過早死亡最多減少12%(95%置信區間10-13),溫室氣體排放最多減少84%;淡水使用最多增加16%,而在動物性食物攝取低或中等的國家幾乎沒有效果。
  2. 2
    減少體重過輕和超重使過早死亡最多減少10%(95%置信區間9-11),並適度改善營養水平;全球所有環境影響的變化均小於15%,高收入和中等收入國家的影響減少,而低收入國家的資源使用增加。
  3. 3
    能量平衡的低肉飲食模式可提供大多數營養素的充足供應,並使過早死亡減少19%(95%置信區間18-20,彈性素食)至22%(18-24,純素食)。
  4. 4
    這些模式使溫室氣體排放減少54-87%、氮肥使用減少23-25%、磷肥使用減少18-21%、耕地使用減少8-11%、淡水使用減少2-11%,但低收入國家的耕地、淡水和磷肥使用例外。

限制與不確定性

  1. 1
    這些是基於假設飲食改變的模型估計,並非改變飲食的族群中觀察到的結果。
  2. 2
    結果因地區而異:作者指出,動物性食物攝取低或中等的地區收益很小,低收入國家飲食多樣化時資源使用可能增加。
  3. 3
    危險因素估計依賴已有證據中的9個與飲食和體重相關的危險因素,摘要也沒有說明足跡資料的不確定性。
  4. 4
    本解讀僅基於摘要。

日常健康啟示

研究支援這樣的看法:倡導能量平衡和以植物性食物為主的膳食指南,可能同時有益於健康和環境,富裕國家尤其如此。它無法預測某個人改變飲食會帶來什麼,營養需求因人而異,個人方案應諮詢營養師或醫師。

如何連結自己的資料

這是國家層面的政策模型,不適合自己去記錄。如果你記錄飲食,可以看幾週內自己植物性與動物性食物的比例,但這篇論文並沒有把這些數字與個人風險聯絡起來。

如何理解這類證據

索引未明確指出具體研究設計,應先讀方法;核對族群、對照、結果和不確定性,再判斷能否作因果解釋。

作者的結構化摘要 English

以下英文摘要依所記錄的開放授權轉載,屬於作者原始材料,並非 MoveVitals 解讀。上方已提供研究解讀,分別說明作者結果與本站解釋;重要結論可直接查核原文。

Background

Sustainable diets are intended to address the increasing health and environmental concerns related to food production and consumption. Although many candidates for sustainable diets have emerged, a consistent and joint environmental and health analysis of these diets has not been done at a regional level. Using an integrated health and environmental modelling framework for more than 150 countries, we examined three different approaches to sustainable diets motivated by environmental, food security, and public health objectives.

Methods

In this global modelling analysis, we combined analyses of nutrient levels, diet-related and weight-related chronic disease mortality, and environmental impacts for more than 150 countries in three sets of diet scenarios. The first set, based on environmental objectives, replaced 25-100% of animal-source foods with plant-based foods. The second set, based on food security objectives, reduced levels of underweight, overweight, and obesity by 25-100%. The third set, based on public health objectives, consisted of four energy-balanced dietary patterns: flexitarian, pescatarian, vegetarian, and vegan. In the nutrient analysis, we calculated nutrient intake and changes in adequacy based on international recommendations and a global dataset of nutrient content and supply. In the health analysis, we estimated changes in mortality using a comparative risk assessment with nine diet and weight-related risk factors. In the environmental analysis, we combined country-specific and food group-specific footprints for greenhouse gas emissions, cropland use, freshwater use, nitrogen application, and phosphorus application to analyse the relationship between the health and environmental impacts of dietary change.

Findings

Following environmental objectives by replacing animal-source foods with plant-based ones was particularly effective in high-income countries for improving nutrient levels, lowering premature mortality (reduction of up to 12% [95% CI 10-13] with complete replacement), and reducing some environmental impacts, in particular greenhouse gas emissions (reductions of up to 84%). However, it also increased freshwater use (increases of up to 16%) and had little effectiveness in countries with low or moderate consumption of animal-source foods. Following food-security objectives by reducing underweight and overweight led to similar reductions in premature mortality (reduction of up to 10% [95% CI 9-11]), and moderately improved nutrient levels. However, it led to only small reductions in environmental impacts at the global level (all impacts changed by <15%), with reduced impacts in high-income and middle-income countries, and increased resource use in low-income countries. Following public health objectives by adopting energy-balanced, low-meat dietary patterns that are in line with available evidence on healthy eating led to an adequate nutrient supply for most nutrients, and large reductions in premature mortality (reduction of 19% [95% CI 18-20] for the flexitarian diet to 22% [18-24] for the vegan diet). It also markedly reduced environmental impacts globally (reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 54-87%, nitrogen application by 23-25%, phosphorus application by 18-21%, cropland use by 8-11%, and freshwater use by 2-11%) and in most regions, except for some environmental domains (cropland use, freshwater use, and phosphorus application) in low-income countries.

Interpretation

Approaches for sustainable diets are context specific and can result in concurrent reductions in environmental and health impacts globally and in most regions, particularly in high-income and middle-income countries, but they can also increase resource use in low-income countries when diets diversify. A public health strategy focused on improving energy balance and dietary changes towards predominantly plant-based diets that are in line with evidence on healthy eating is a suitable approach for sustainable diets. Updating national dietary guidelines to reflect the latest evidence on healthy eating can by itself be important for improving health and reducing environmental impacts and can complement broader and more explicit criteria of sustainability.

Funding

Wellcome Trust, EAT, CGIAR, and British Heart Foundation.

來源與署名

Health and nutritional aspects of sustainable diet strategies and their association with environmental impacts: a global modelling analysis with country-level detail.

Springmann M, Wiebe K, Mason-D'Croz D, Sulser TB, Rayner M, Scarborough P.

The Lancet. Planetary health · 2018-10-01

DOI: 10.1016/s2542-5196(18)30206-7 ↗PubMed · 30318102 ↗Europe PMC · 所記錄的開放授權: cc by ↗

摘要著作權歸原作者,依來源紀錄的開放授權轉載。中文譯文協助閱讀,英文摘要供查核術語及具體數值;本站的方法學解釋與作者結論分別呈現。

MoveVitals 編輯解讀 · 健康教育內容 · 未記錄個人臨床審閱

來源查核日期 2026-11-01

實用健康指南

放在一起讀

·隨機試驗統合分析

更早的進食視窗與更大的體重和胰島素獲益相關,優於晚間進食

彙總41項隨機對照試驗(2287名參與者,介入時間中位數8週)發現,限時進食比日常飲食體重低2.15 kg(95%置信區間−2.56至−1.74),而早吃比晚吃體重多降1.15 kg(95%置信區間−1.86至−0.45)。多數試驗較短,只有6個研究組檢驗了早間進食,結局是身體和血液指標,不是心臟病發作或死亡。

BMJ Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·隨機對照試驗

限熱量飲食再加上午8點至下午4點進食視窗,1年減重無明顯額外優勢

139名肥胖患者都按限制熱量的飲食進食,其中一組再加上上午8:00至下午4:00的進食視窗,12個月平均體重變化為−8.0 kg,單純限熱量組為−6.3 kg。淨差值−1.8 kg(95%置信區間−4.0至0.4;P=0.11)無統計學意義,該區間既不能排除視窗確有獲益,也不能排除毫無作用。

The New England Journal of Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·隨機對照試驗

20人住院試驗:超加工飲食讓人每天多攝取508 kcal並增重

20名成年人在醫院研究病房住了28天,兩種選單各吃2週、想吃多少吃多少:超加工選單讓他們每天多攝取508 kcal(±106,標準誤,P=0.0001),體重增加0.9 kg;未加工選單則讓體重減輕0.9 kg。樣本小、週期短、食物全程由研究方提供,既不能說明日常生活中的長期結果,也無法確定是食物的哪種特點導致多吃。

Cell Metabolism

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·隨機對照試驗

地中海飲食加橄欖油或堅果與心血管事件減少相關(更正後的試驗)

在7447名55至80歲、心血管風險較高的西班牙成年人中,被分到加特級初榨橄欖油(風險比0.69,95%置信區間0.53至0.91)或加堅果(風險比0.72,0.54至0.95)的地中海飲食組,發生主要心血管事件的風險低於被告知減少脂肪的對照組。試驗存在隨機化失誤,2013年的報告已撤回並重新估算,證據有力但並不完美。

The New England Journal of Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
營養與代謝 →