Aller au contenu
Santé mentale et cognitionMéta-analyse d’essais6 min read

Strength training eased depressive symptoms in 33 trials, but blinded trials found less

Collectif éditorial MoveVitals · Study published · Reading updated

Original paper:Association of Efficacy of Resistance Exercise Training With Depressive Symptoms: Meta-analysis and Meta-regression Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials · JAMA Psychiatry · 2018 · Article original ↗

À retenir

Pooling 33 randomized trials with 1877 participants, resistance exercise training was followed by a moderate reduction in depressive symptoms compared with non-active control conditions (mean effect size 0.66, 95% CI 0.48 to 0.83; P < .001). Trials that blinded allocation and/or assessment found smaller reductions, and results differed a great deal between trials (I² 76.0%), so the true effect is likely smaller and less certain than the headline number.

Study design

Méta-analyse d’essais

Reading basis

Published abstract

Reading focus

Design & applicability

Cette explication éditoriale existe en anglais, chinois simplifié et chinois traditionnel. Cette interface affiche la lecture en anglais.

Question de recherche

Strength training is well known to improve physical health, but much less was known about its link with mental health, and no one had pooled the trial evidence on whether it eases depression. The authors set out to estimate how strongly resistance exercise training (RET) is associated with lower depressive symptoms in randomized trials.

They also asked whether the size of the effect depends on four things chosen in advance: how much training was prescribed in total, whether participants were healthy or physically or mentally ill, whether allocation and assessment were blinded, and whether the training produced a significant gain in strength.

Population et méthode

This is a meta-analysis and meta-regression of randomized clinical trials, published in JAMA Psychiatry in 2018. The authors searched Google Scholar, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, PubMed and Web of Science for articles published before August 2017. Eligible trials randomized participants to resistance exercise training or to a non-active control condition; 947 participants were in the training groups and 930 in the control groups. The abstract does not report the participants' ages, the exact type of control condition or how trial quality was scored, and this reading is based on the abstract alone.

The outcome was depressive symptoms, measured with validated scales at baseline and at mid-intervention and/or post-intervention. The authors computed Hedges d effect sizes and pooled them with random-effects models, which allow the true effect to differ from trial to trial. The analysis yielded 54 effects from 33 trials involving 1877 participants. Heterogeneity was quantified with Cochran's Q and I², and the authors also report a number needed to treat. Meta-regression then tested whether four pre-specified moderators (total prescribed training volume, health status, blinding of allocation and/or assessment, and significant strength improvement) accounted for variation in the effect.

Résultats

  1. 1
    Adults who did resistance training had a moderate-sized reduction in depressive symptoms compared with non-active controls: the mean effect was 0.66 (95% CI 0.48 to 0.83; z = 7.35; P < .001), pooled from 54 effects in 33 trials with 1877 participants. The authors report a number needed to treat of 4.
  2. 2
    The trials disagreed with each other more than chance would explain. Heterogeneity was significant (total Q = 216.92 on 53 degrees of freedom, P < .001; I² 76.0%, 95% CI 72.7% to 79.0%), and sampling error accounted for only 32.9% of the observed variance. The single average therefore hides a wide spread of results.
  3. 3
    Trials with blinded allocation and/or assessment found smaller reductions in depressive symptoms. This was the one moderator that did change the result, and the abstract does not give the size of the gap, so the 0.66 average likely overstates what better-controlled trials would show.
  4. 4
    Three other moderators were not significantly associated with the benefit: the total volume of training prescribed, whether participants were healthy or physically or mentally ill, and whether strength improved significantly. The authors conclude that the reduction held regardless of these factors, though the abstract gives no separate numbers for each subgroup.
  5. 5
    Because the volume and strength moderators were not significant, the analysis does not show that more training, or a larger strength gain, brought a larger mood benefit. A non-significant result here is not proof of no relationship, particularly with only 33 trials.

Limites et incertitude

  1. 1
    The authors call for better-quality randomized trials that blind both allocation and assessment, and the pooled result itself shows why: trials with blinded allocation and/or assessment gave smaller reductions.
  2. 2
    The authors note that trials comparing resistance training with other empirically supported treatments for depressive symptoms are still needed. Every comparison here was against a non-active control, so the analysis cannot say whether strength training works as well as, or better than, therapy or medication.
  3. 3
    Heterogeneity was significant and large (I² 76.0%), which the authors report. Our observation: the abstract does not explain what drives that spread, so a single average of 0.66 may not describe any particular trial or program well.
  4. 4
    Our observation: participants in an exercise trial know which group they are in and depressive symptoms are usually self-rated, so expectation could add to the measured benefit. Outcomes were taken at mid-intervention and/or post-intervention, so the abstract does not show whether the benefit lasts after training stops, and it does not say how several effects from the same trial were handled.
  5. 5
    This reading is based on the abstract only, so the size of the blinding gap, the individual trial details and the moderator-by-moderator estimates are not covered.

Mise en perspective

If you are considering strength training for low mood, this analysis supports it as a reasonable option to talk through with a clinician alongside other care. Across 33 trials, groups that lifted weights ended with fewer depressive symptoms than groups that did nothing special, and the authors found this regardless of health status, prescribed volume or strength gains.

It does not show that strength training replaces therapy or medication, that a particular program or amount works best, or that the benefit lasts. The better-blinded trials found smaller effects and the trials varied widely, so expect a real but more modest benefit than 0.66 suggests. Decisions about starting, changing or stopping treatment for depression belong with a clinician.

Vos données

Log the training itself (sessions per week, exercises, sets and reps, or total weight lifted) in a notebook or app, and keep it separate from how you feel. Because the review found the mood effect regardless of strength gains, do not judge progress by your lifts alone. Rate mood and daily functioning with the same simple scale at the same time each week, and treat wearable stress scores or HRV as context rather than as a measure of depression.

Comprendre ce type de preuve

Pooling trials can improve precision, but compare populations, controls, bias and uncertainty. Network rankings include indirect evidence and do not identify a universal best treatment.

Sources et attribution

Association of Efficacy of Resistance Exercise Training With Depressive Symptoms: Meta-analysis and Meta-regression Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials

JAMA Psychiatry · 2018-06-01

DOI: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.0572 ↗PubMed · 29800984 ↗

Interprétation éditoriale MoveVitals · contenu éducatif · aucune évaluation clinique individuelle enregistrée

Sources vérifiées 2026-11-01

Guides pratiques

À lire ensemble

·Synthèse de revues

Exercise gave small-to-moderate cognitive gains across 133 reviews of trials

An umbrella review of 133 systematic reviews (2724 trials, 258,279 participants) found that exercise improved general cognition (SMD 0.42, 95% CI 0.37 to 0.47), memory (0.26) and executive function (0.24), with the largest memory gains in children and adolescents and the largest executive function gains in people with ADHD. Most of the reviews (94) were rated critically low in quality and the effects were smaller in the best-rated ones (0.23 for general cognition), and the outcomes were test scores, not dementia.

British Journal of Sports Medicine

Explications approfondiesLire l’étude →
·Méta-analyse observationnelle

More daily steps linked to fewer depressive symptoms across 33 studies of adults

Pooling 33 observational studies of 96,173 adults, higher daily step counts went with fewer depressive symptoms, and in the two prospective cohorts that could be pooled, 7000 or more steps a day went with a lower risk of depression than fewer (RR 0.69, 95% CI 0.62-0.77). Most studies were cross-sectional, so low mood may be reducing steps as much as steps affect mood, and the authors say the prediction intervals call for caution.

JAMA Network Open

Explications approfondiesLire l’étude →
·Méta-analyse d’essais

Exercise eased depression in 218 trials, but confidence in the evidence is low

In a network meta-analysis of 218 trials with 14,170 people who met criteria for major depression, walking or jogging, yoga, strength training, mixed aerobic exercise and tai chi or qigong each gave moderate reductions in depression compared with active controls (walking or jogging: Hedges' g −0.62, 95% credible interval −0.80 to −0.45). Confidence in the evidence was low for walking or jogging and very low for the other treatments, mainly because only one study met the low-risk-of-bias criteria.

BMJ

Explications approfondiesLire l’étude →
·Synthèse de revues

Physical activity eased depression and anxiety across 97 reviews of trials

Across 97 systematic reviews that pooled 1039 randomized trials with 128,119 participants, physical activity had medium effects on depression (median effect size −0.43) and anxiety (−0.42) compared with usual care, and higher-intensity activity went with larger gains. Most of those reviews (77) were rated critically low in quality, and the evidence mainly concerns mild-to-moderate symptoms.

British Journal of Sports Medicine

Explications approfondiesLire l’étude →
Santé mentale et cognition →