跳到正文
心理與認知健康隨機對照試驗3 分鐘閱讀

學校體育課加一年高強度運動:青少年體能和心理健康未見改善

MoveVitals 編輯部 · 研究發表 · 解讀更新

原文:The effect of a one-year vigorous physical activity intervention on fitness, cognitive performance and mental health in young adolescents: the Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial. · The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity · 2021 · 論文原文 ↗

先看重點

在英格蘭104所中學的18261名12-13歲學生中,一學年裡在體育課上增加10分鐘高強度運動,並未顯著改善體能、認知表現或心理健康(均為p > 0.05)。試驗脫落率高、依從性低,所以陰性結果可能源於執行不到位,而不是這種方法無效。

證據類型

隨機對照試驗

解讀依據

公開摘要

閱讀重點

對照與不確定性

研究在問什麼

青少年期大腦發育迅速,學校裡的短時高強度運動或許是支援思維和心理健康的簡便辦法。主要結局(數學成績)此前已報告為陰性,這裡作者檢驗的是次要結局:心肺體能、認知和心理健康。

研究對象與方法

這是一項整群隨機對照試驗(Fit to Study),納入英格蘭南部和中部104所公立中學的8年級學生(n = 18,261,12-13歲)。學校被隨機分到介入組(n = 52)或常規體育課對照組;介入組的體育教師在2017-2018學年每節體育課增加10分鐘高強度身體活動(高強度間歇訓練式方案)。次要結局包括體能(20米往返跑)、認知表現(執行功能、關係記憶、處理速度)和心理健康(長處與困難問卷、自尊)。意向性治療分析採用線性模型和結構方程模型,並使用整群穩健標準誤,另估計了依從者平均因果效應(CACE)。這些次要指標於2017年9月18日追溯註冊。

主要發現

以下為作者報告的結果。數值須連同族群和不確定性一起閱讀。

  1. 1
    介入沒有顯著改善心肺體能、認知表現(執行功能、關係記憶、處理速度)或心理健康(均為p > 0.05)。
  2. 2
    按性別、社會經濟狀況或基線體能分層,效應無顯著差異。
  3. 3
    體能的變化與認知或心理健康的變化無顯著關係。
  4. 4
    考慮依從性的CACE分析結果與意向性治療分析一致。

限制與不確定性

  1. 1
    脫落率高、介入依從性低,學生可能沒有獲得預期劑量的運動。
  2. 2
    作者指出實施保真度低,所以陰性結果未必代表一個執行良好的專案的效果。
  3. 3
    次要結局是在試驗註冊之後追溯註冊的。
  4. 4
    本解讀僅基於摘要。

日常健康啟示

就這裡的實施情況而言,體育課增加10分鐘運動,並未在12-13歲學生中帶來可測的體能、認知或心理健康變化。這並不排除執行更好或時間更長的專案可能有益,也不影響運動本身的價值。對青少年心理健康的擔憂,請諮詢臨床醫師或學校。

如何連結自己的資料

如果青少年佩戴運動手環,相關資料包括每天高強度活動分鐘數、運動時心率和睡眠。手環無法顯示體能或認知是否發生了本試驗所測量的那種變化,請在同一裝置和同樣習慣下觀察數月的變化。

如何理解這類證據

隨機分組有助於因果推斷,仍須檢查分配、盲法、失去追蹤、追蹤時間和具體對照;標為隨機試驗不自動意味著高確定性。

作者的結構化摘要 English

以下英文摘要依所記錄的開放授權轉載,屬於作者原始材料,並非 MoveVitals 解讀。上方已提供研究解讀,分別說明作者結果與本站解釋;重要結論可直接查核原文。

Background

Physical activity (PA) may positively stimulate the brain, cognition and mental health during adolescence, a period of dynamic neurobiological development. High-intensity interval training (HIIT) or vigorous PA interventions are time-efficient, scalable and can be easily implemented in existing school curricula, yet their effects on cognitive, academic and mental health outcomes are unclear. The primary aim of the Fit to Study trial was to investigate whether a pragmatic and scalable HIIT-style VPA intervention delivered during school physical education (PE) could improve attainment in maths. The primary outcome has previously been reported and was null. Here, we report the effect of the intervention on prespecified secondary outcomes, including cardiorespiratory fitness, cognitive performance, and mental health in young adolescents.

Methods

The Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial included Year 8 pupils (n = 18,261, aged 12-13) from 104 secondary state schools in South/Mid-England. Schools were randomised into an intervention condition (n = 52), in which PE teachers delivered an additional 10 min of VPA per PE lesson for one academic year (2017-2018), or into a "PE as usual" control condition. Secondary outcomes included assessments of cardiorespiratory fitness (20-m shuttle run), cognitive performance (executive functions, relational memory and processing speed) and mental health (Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire and self-esteem measures). The primary intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis used linear models and structural equation models with cluster-robust standard errors to test for intervention effects. A complier-average causal effect (CACE) was estimated using a two-stage least squares procedure.

Results

The HIIT-style VPA intervention did not significantly improve cardiorespiratory fitness, cognitive performance (executive functions, relational memory or processed speed), or mental health (all p > 0.05). Subgroup analyses showed no significant moderation of intervention effects by sex, socioeconomic status or baseline fitness levels. Changes in cardiorespiratory fitness were not significantly related to changes in cognitive or mental health outcomes. The trial was marked by high drop-out and low intervention compliance. Findings from the CACE analysis were in line with those from the ITT analysis.

Conclusion

The one-academic year HIIT-style VPA intervention delivered during regular school PE did not significantly improve fitness, cognitive performance or mental health, but these findings should be interpreted with caution given low implementation fidelity and high drop-out. Well-controlled, large-scale, school-based trials that examine the effectiveness of HIIT-style interventions to enhance cognitive and mental health outcomes are warranted.

Trial registration

ISRCTN registry, 15,730,512 . Trial protocol and analysis plan for primary outcome prospectively registered on 30th March 2017. ClinicalTrials.gov , NCT03286725 . Secondary measures (focus of current manuscript) retrospectively registered on 18 September 2017.

來源與署名

The effect of a one-year vigorous physical activity intervention on fitness, cognitive performance and mental health in young adolescents: the Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial.

Wassenaar TM, Wheatley CM, Beale N, Nichols T, Salvan P, Meaney A, Atherton K, Diaz-Ordaz K, Dawes H, Johansen-Berg H.

The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity · 2021-03-31

DOI: 10.1186/s12966-021-01113-y ↗PubMed · 33789683 ↗Europe PMC · 所記錄的開放授權: cc by ↗

摘要著作權歸原作者,依來源紀錄的開放授權轉載。中文譯文協助閱讀,英文摘要供查核術語及具體數值;本站的方法學解釋與作者結論分別呈現。

MoveVitals 編輯解讀 · 健康教育內容 · 未記錄個人臨床審閱

來源查核日期 2026-11-01

實用健康指南

放在一起讀

·回顧的回顧

運動對認知有小到中等程度的改善:133項系統評價的傘狀綜述

對133項系統評價(共2724項試驗、258,279名參與者)的傘狀綜述發現,運動改善了總體認知(SMD 0.42,95% CI 0.37至0.47)、記憶(0.26)和執行功能(0.24),記憶改善在兒童和青少年中最大,執行功能改善在注意缺陷多動障礙(ADHD)患者中最大。多數評價(94項)質量被評為極低,評級最好的評價中效應更小(總體認知為0.23),而且結局是測試得分,不是失智。

British Journal of Sports Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·觀察研究統合分析

每天步數越多,憂鬱症狀越少:33項觀察性研究的統合分析

統合分析彙總了33項觀察性研究、共96,173名成年人,每日步數越多,憂鬱症狀越少;在可合併的2項前瞻性佇列中,每天走7000步及以上者的憂鬱風險低於少於7000步者(RR 0.69,95% CI 0.62至0.77)。多數研究是橫斷面研究,情緒低落也可能讓人走得更少,作者還指出預測區間提示結論需謹慎對待。

JAMA Network Open

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·隨機試驗統合分析

運動可緩解憂鬱,但證據把握度低:218項試驗的網狀統合分析

這項網狀統合分析彙總了218項試驗、14,170名符合重性憂鬱診斷標準的參與者,與積極對照相比,步行或慢跑、瑜伽、力量訓練、混合有氧運動以及太極或氣功都使憂鬱症狀出現中等程度的下降(步行或慢跑的Hedges』 g −0.62,95%可信區間−0.80至−0.45)。不過只有一項研究達到低偏倚風險標準,因此證據把握度對步行或慢跑為低,對其他療法為極低。

BMJ

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
·回顧的回顧

身體活動可減輕憂鬱和焦慮:97項系統評價的傘狀綜述

97項系統評價彙總了1039項隨機對照試驗、128,119名參與者,與常規照護相比,身體活動對憂鬱(中位數效應量−0.43)和焦慮(−0.42)有中等程度的改善,強度越高改善越大。不過其中77項綜述的質量被評為極低,證據主要針對輕至中度症狀。

British Journal of Sports Medicine

重點論文精講閱讀論文 →
心理與認知健康 →