跳到正文
日常活动与长寿随机试验荟萃分析3 分钟阅读

游戏化干预让身体活动小到中度增加,随访时效果减弱

MoveVitals 编辑部 · 研究发表 · 解读更新

原文:Evaluating the Effectiveness of Gamification on Physical Activity: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. · Journal of medical Internet research · 2022 · 论文原文 ↗

先看重点

合并16项随机对照试验、共2407名参与者,与对照相比,游戏化干预使身体活动小到中度增加(Hedges g 0.42,95%置信区间0.14至0.69)。结束后平均14周的随访中效应小得多(g 0.15),作者也表示还需要更严谨的试验。

证据类型

随机试验荟萃分析

解读依据

公开摘要

阅读重点

方法与适用范围

研究在问什么

利用积分、挑战和奖励等游戏元素促进运动很流行,但文献中的结果并不一致。作者检验了游戏化干预对身体活动(PA)和久坐行为是否有效、对谁有效,以及效果能否持续。

研究了谁,如何研究

对2010年至2020年发表的英文随机对照试验进行系统综述与荟萃分析,检索了PubMed、Embase、Scopus、Web of Science和Cochrane中央对照试验注册库。纳入的试验须在日常生活中使用游戏化干预,设有积极或非积极对照组,并测量了身体活动或久坐行为。采用随机效应模型做荟萃分析,并通过敏感性分析、影响分析和发表偏倚分析检验结果的稳健性。效应以Hedges g表示。

主要发现

以下为作者报告的结果。数字须连同人群和不确定性一起阅读。

  1. 1
    对16项研究、2407名参与者的主分析显示,对身体活动有小到中度的合并效应(Hedges g 0.42,95%置信区间0.14至0.69)。
  2. 2
    与等待名单等非积极对照相比,效应显著(g 0.58,95%置信区间0.08至1.07);与采用非游戏化身体活动干预的积极对照相比,效应也显著(g 0.23,95%置信区间0.05至0.41)。
  3. 3
    亚组之间(成人与青少年、健康人群与慢性病成人)无显著差异,年龄、性别和BMI与效应也没有交互作用。
  4. 4
    干预结束后平均14周的随访中,效应减弱,为极小到小(g 0.15,95%置信区间0.07至0.23)。

局限与不确定性

  1. 1
    主效应的95%置信区间较宽(0.14至0.69),对非积极对照的效应区间(0.08至1.07)更宽,真实效应可能较小,也可能相当大。
  2. 2
    仅合并了16项试验,且只限英文发表;作者自己也指出需要未来更严谨的试验来证实这些发现。
  3. 3
    作者将随访时的效应作为并非新鲜感所致的证据,但该效应远小于即时效应,且平均只随访了14周。本解读仅基于摘要。

对日常健康的启示

挑战、积分之类的游戏式功能似乎能让人多动一点,而且表现略好于没有游戏元素的同类项目。项目结束后获益会缩小,所以游戏化应用更可能在你持续使用时有帮助,而不是单靠它养成长久习惯。

如何联系自己的数据

如果你的运动手环有连续打卡、徽章或步数挑战,请用同一台设备对比开始前后每周的平均步数或活动分钟数,看是否真的改变。挑战结束后平均值若回落,就与本综述中随访效应较弱的结果一致。

如何理解这类证据

合并试验可提高精度,但人群、对照、偏倚与不确定性仍重要;网络排名包含间接证据,不是通用最佳方案。

作者的结构化摘要 English

以下英文摘要按记录的开放许可转载,属于作者原始材料,不是 MoveVitals 的解读。上方已提供研究解读,分别说明作者结果与本站解释;重要结论可直接核对原文。

Background

Gamification refers to the use of game elements in nongame contexts. The use of gamification to change behaviors and promote physical activity (PA) is a promising avenue for tackling the global physical inactivity pandemic and the current prevalence of chronic diseases. However, there is no evidence of the effectiveness of gamified interventions with the existence of mixed results in the literature.

Objective

The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to evaluate the effectiveness of gamified interventions and their health care potential by testing the generalizability and sustainability of their influence on PA and sedentary behavior.

Methods

A total of 5 electronic databases (PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials) were searched for randomized controlled trials published in English from 2010 to 2020. Eligibility criteria were based on the components of the participants, interventions, comparators, and outcomes framework. Studies were included when they used gamified interventions in daily life with an active or inactive control group and when they assessed a PA or sedentary behavior outcome. We conducted meta-analyses using a random-effects model approach. Sensitivity analyses, influence analyses, and publication bias analyses were performed to examine the robustness of our results.

Results

The main meta-analysis performed on 16 studies and 2407 participants revealed a small to medium summary effect of gamified interventions on PA behavior (Hedges g=0.42, 95% CI 0.14-0.69). No statistical difference among different subgroups (adults vs adolescents and healthy participants vs adults with chronic diseases) and no interaction effects with moderators such as age, gender, or BMI were found, suggesting good generalizability of gamified interventions to different user populations. The effect was statistically significant when gamified interventions were compared with inactive control groups, such as waiting lists (Hedges g=0.58, 95% CI 0.08-1.07), and active control groups that included a nongamified PA intervention (Hedges g=0.23, 95% CI 0.05-0.41). This suggests that gamified interventions are not only efficient in changing behavior but also more effective compared with other behavioral interventions. The long-term effect (measured with follow-up averaging 14 weeks after the end of the intervention) was weaker, with a very small to small effect (Hedges g=0.15, 95% CI 0.07-0.23).

Conclusions

This meta-analysis confirms that gamified interventions are promising for promoting PA in various populations. Additional analyses revealed that this effect persists after the follow-up period, suggesting that it is not just a novelty effect caused by the playful nature of gamification, and that gamified products appear effective compared with equivalent nongamified PA interventions. Future rigorous trials are required to confirm these findings.

来源与署名

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Gamification on Physical Activity: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials.

Mazeas A, Duclos M, Pereira B, Chalabaev A.

Journal of medical Internet research · 2022-01-04

DOI: 10.2196/26779 ↗PubMed · 34982715 ↗Europe PMC · 记录的开放许可: cc by ↗

摘要版权归原作者,依据来源记录的开放许可转载。中文译文辅助阅读,英文摘要用于核对术语与具体数值;本站的方法学解释与作者结论分别呈现。

MoveVitals 编辑解读 · 健康教育内容 · 未记录个人临床审阅

来源核验日期 2026-11-01

实用健康指南

放在一起读

·观察研究荟萃分析

每天7000步与2000步相比:死亡、心血管疾病和痴呆风险较低

与每天2000步相比,每天7000步与全因死亡的风险比0.53(95%置信区间0.46至0.60,14项研究)、心血管疾病的0.75(0.67至0.85)和痴呆的0.62(0.53至0.73)相关;癌症发病差异不显著(0.94,0.87至1.01)。多个结局只有2至4项研究支撑,证据确定性从中等到极低不等。

The Lancet Public Health

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
·队列研究

不运动的人:日常生活中每天约3次1至2分钟的剧烈活动与更低死亡率相关

在英国生物银行25241名自述没有休闲运动的成年人中,加速度计记录到的剧烈活动,样本中位数为每天3次、每次1或2分钟,与没有此类活动者相比,全因死亡和癌症死亡风险低38%至40%,心血管疾病死亡风险低48%至49%(平均随访6.9年,852例死亡)。这是观察性研究,只有一周的手腕数据,剧烈程度由算法判定,不能证明增加这类短时剧烈活动会降低死亡风险。

Nature Medicine

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
·观察研究荟萃分析

每日步数越多死亡率越低:60岁及以上约6000至8000步趋平,年轻者约8000至10000步

汇总15个队列(47471名成年人,3013例死亡,中位随访7.1年)后,每日步数第二、第三、第四四分位组(中位数5801、7842、10901步)相对最低组(中位数3553步)的死亡风险比分别为0.60、0.55、0.47。风险下降在60岁及以上人群约6000至8000步时趋平,在更年轻人群约8000至10000步时趋平。数据来自观察性研究,只测量了一周步数,且多用佩戴在腰部的研究级设备。

The Lancet Public Health

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
·观察研究荟萃分析

36383名成年人的加速度计数据:任何强度活动都与较低死亡率相关

汇总8个队列(36383名成年人,平均年龄62.6岁,中位随访5.8年内2149人死亡)后,加速度计测得的总活动量最高四分位组相对最低组的死亡风险比为0.27(95%置信区间0.23至0.32),久坐最多的一组为2.63(1.94至3.56);仅看低强度活动也呈同样趋势,最高组为0.38(0.28至0.51)。这是针对美国和西欧40岁及以上人群的观察性关联,因病减少活动和混杂因素仍无法排除。

BMJ

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
日常活动与长寿 →