跳到正文
心理与认知健康随机对照试验3 分钟阅读

学校体育课加一年高强度运动:青少年体能和心理健康未见改善

MoveVitals 编辑部 · 研究发表 · 解读更新

原文:The effect of a one-year vigorous physical activity intervention on fitness, cognitive performance and mental health in young adolescents: the Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial. · The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity · 2021 · 论文原文 ↗

先看重点

在英格兰104所中学的18261名12-13岁学生中,一学年里在体育课上增加10分钟高强度运动,并未显著改善体能、认知表现或心理健康(均为p > 0.05)。试验脱落率高、依从性低,所以阴性结果可能源于执行不到位,而不是这种方法无效。

证据类型

随机对照试验

解读依据

公开摘要

阅读重点

对照与不确定性

研究在问什么

青少年期大脑发育迅速,学校里的短时高强度运动或许是支持思维和心理健康的简便办法。主要结局(数学成绩)此前已报告为阴性,这里作者检验的是次要结局:心肺体能、认知和心理健康。

研究了谁,如何研究

这是一项整群随机对照试验(Fit to Study),纳入英格兰南部和中部104所公立中学的8年级学生(n = 18,261,12-13岁)。学校被随机分到干预组(n = 52)或常规体育课对照组;干预组的体育教师在2017-2018学年每节体育课增加10分钟高强度身体活动(高强度间歇训练式方案)。次要结局包括体能(20米往返跑)、认知表现(执行功能、关系记忆、处理速度)和心理健康(长处与困难问卷、自尊)。意向性治疗分析采用线性模型和结构方程模型,并使用整群稳健标准误,另估计了依从者平均因果效应(CACE)。这些次要指标于2017年9月18日追溯注册。

主要发现

以下为作者报告的结果。数字须连同人群和不确定性一起阅读。

  1. 1
    干预没有显著改善心肺体能、认知表现(执行功能、关系记忆、处理速度)或心理健康(均为p > 0.05)。
  2. 2
    按性别、社会经济状况或基线体能分层,效应无显著差异。
  3. 3
    体能的变化与认知或心理健康的变化无显著关系。
  4. 4
    考虑依从性的CACE分析结果与意向性治疗分析一致。

局限与不确定性

  1. 1
    脱落率高、干预依从性低,学生可能没有获得预期剂量的运动。
  2. 2
    作者指出实施保真度低,所以阴性结果未必代表一个执行良好的项目的效果。
  3. 3
    次要结局是在试验注册之后追溯注册的。
  4. 4
    本解读仅基于摘要。

对日常健康的启示

就这里的实施情况而言,体育课增加10分钟运动,并未在12-13岁学生中带来可测的体能、认知或心理健康变化。这并不排除执行更好或时间更长的项目可能有益,也不影响运动本身的价值。对青少年心理健康的担忧,请咨询临床医生或学校。

如何联系自己的数据

如果青少年佩戴运动手环,相关数据包括每天高强度活动分钟数、运动时心率和睡眠。手环无法显示体能或认知是否发生了本试验所测量的那种变化,请在同一设备和同样习惯下观察数月的变化。

如何理解这类证据

随机分组有助于因果推断,仍须检查分配、盲法、失访、随访时间和具体对照;标为随机试验不自动意味着高确定性。

作者的结构化摘要 English

以下英文摘要按记录的开放许可转载,属于作者原始材料,不是 MoveVitals 的解读。上方已提供研究解读,分别说明作者结果与本站解释;重要结论可直接核对原文。

Background

Physical activity (PA) may positively stimulate the brain, cognition and mental health during adolescence, a period of dynamic neurobiological development. High-intensity interval training (HIIT) or vigorous PA interventions are time-efficient, scalable and can be easily implemented in existing school curricula, yet their effects on cognitive, academic and mental health outcomes are unclear. The primary aim of the Fit to Study trial was to investigate whether a pragmatic and scalable HIIT-style VPA intervention delivered during school physical education (PE) could improve attainment in maths. The primary outcome has previously been reported and was null. Here, we report the effect of the intervention on prespecified secondary outcomes, including cardiorespiratory fitness, cognitive performance, and mental health in young adolescents.

Methods

The Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial included Year 8 pupils (n = 18,261, aged 12-13) from 104 secondary state schools in South/Mid-England. Schools were randomised into an intervention condition (n = 52), in which PE teachers delivered an additional 10 min of VPA per PE lesson for one academic year (2017-2018), or into a "PE as usual" control condition. Secondary outcomes included assessments of cardiorespiratory fitness (20-m shuttle run), cognitive performance (executive functions, relational memory and processing speed) and mental health (Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire and self-esteem measures). The primary intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis used linear models and structural equation models with cluster-robust standard errors to test for intervention effects. A complier-average causal effect (CACE) was estimated using a two-stage least squares procedure.

Results

The HIIT-style VPA intervention did not significantly improve cardiorespiratory fitness, cognitive performance (executive functions, relational memory or processed speed), or mental health (all p > 0.05). Subgroup analyses showed no significant moderation of intervention effects by sex, socioeconomic status or baseline fitness levels. Changes in cardiorespiratory fitness were not significantly related to changes in cognitive or mental health outcomes. The trial was marked by high drop-out and low intervention compliance. Findings from the CACE analysis were in line with those from the ITT analysis.

Conclusion

The one-academic year HIIT-style VPA intervention delivered during regular school PE did not significantly improve fitness, cognitive performance or mental health, but these findings should be interpreted with caution given low implementation fidelity and high drop-out. Well-controlled, large-scale, school-based trials that examine the effectiveness of HIIT-style interventions to enhance cognitive and mental health outcomes are warranted.

Trial registration

ISRCTN registry, 15,730,512 . Trial protocol and analysis plan for primary outcome prospectively registered on 30th March 2017. ClinicalTrials.gov , NCT03286725 . Secondary measures (focus of current manuscript) retrospectively registered on 18 September 2017.

来源与署名

The effect of a one-year vigorous physical activity intervention on fitness, cognitive performance and mental health in young adolescents: the Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial.

Wassenaar TM, Wheatley CM, Beale N, Nichols T, Salvan P, Meaney A, Atherton K, Diaz-Ordaz K, Dawes H, Johansen-Berg H.

The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity · 2021-03-31

DOI: 10.1186/s12966-021-01113-y ↗PubMed · 33789683 ↗Europe PMC · 记录的开放许可: cc by ↗

摘要版权归原作者,依据来源记录的开放许可转载。中文译文辅助阅读,英文摘要用于核对术语与具体数值;本站的方法学解释与作者结论分别呈现。

MoveVitals 编辑解读 · 健康教育内容 · 未记录个人临床审阅

来源核验日期 2026-11-01

实用健康指南

放在一起读

·综述的综述

运动对认知有小到中等程度的改善:133项系统评价的伞状综述

对133项系统评价(共2724项试验、258,279名参与者)的伞状综述发现,运动改善了总体认知(SMD 0.42,95% CI 0.37至0.47)、记忆(0.26)和执行功能(0.24),记忆改善在儿童和青少年中最大,执行功能改善在注意缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)患者中最大。多数评价(94项)质量被评为极低,评级最好的评价中效应更小(总体认知为0.23),而且结局是测试得分,不是痴呆。

British Journal of Sports Medicine

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
·观察研究荟萃分析

每天步数越多,抑郁症状越少:33项观察性研究的荟萃分析

荟萃分析汇总了33项观察性研究、共96,173名成年人,每日步数越多,抑郁症状越少;在可合并的2项前瞻性队列中,每天走7000步及以上者的抑郁风险低于少于7000步者(RR 0.69,95% CI 0.62至0.77)。多数研究是横断面研究,情绪低落也可能让人走得更少,作者还指出预测区间提示结论需谨慎对待。

JAMA Network Open

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
·随机试验荟萃分析

运动可缓解抑郁,但证据把握度低:218项试验的网状荟萃分析

这项网状荟萃分析汇总了218项试验、14,170名符合重性抑郁诊断标准的参与者,与积极对照相比,步行或慢跑、瑜伽、力量训练、混合有氧运动以及太极或气功都使抑郁症状出现中等程度的下降(步行或慢跑的Hedges’ g −0.62,95%可信区间−0.80至−0.45)。不过只有一项研究达到低偏倚风险标准,因此证据把握度对步行或慢跑为低,对其他疗法为极低。

BMJ

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
·综述的综述

身体活动可减轻抑郁和焦虑:97项系统评价的伞状综述

97项系统评价汇总了1039项随机对照试验、128,119名参与者,与常规照护相比,身体活动对抑郁(中位数效应量−0.43)和焦虑(−0.42)有中等程度的改善,强度越高改善越大。不过其中77项综述的质量被评为极低,证据主要针对轻至中度症状。

British Journal of Sports Medicine

重点论文精讲阅读论文 →
心理与认知健康 →