先看重点
在一项为期12个月、纳入101名肥胖绝经后女性的试验中,严格能量限制比中度限制多减重6.6 kg,瘦体重丢失与总体减重成比例,但全髋骨密度下降也更多。这是悉尼的单中心试验,推广时需谨慎。
证据类型
随机对照试验
解读依据
公开摘要
阅读重点
对照与不确定性
研究在问什么
严格限制能量的饮食是治疗肥胖最有效的饮食方式,但人们担心它会损失肌肉、损害体成分。作者比较了严格与中度能量限制在绝经后女性中对瘦体重和其他体成分的长期影响。
研究了谁,如何研究
TEMPO饮食试验是一项为期12个月的单中心随机临床试验,纳入澳大利亚悉尼的101名绝经后女性(2013年3月至2016年7月招募),年龄45至65岁,体重指数30至40,绝经至少5年,每周有组织的身体活动少于3小时。一组进行12个月的中度(25%至35%)能量限制,采用以食物为基础的饮食。另一组先用全代餐饮食进行4个月的严格(65%至75%)限制,再用8个月的中度限制。两组规定蛋白质摄入均为每日每千克实际体重1.0 g,鼓励运动但不监督。主要结局为12个月时的全身瘦体重,次要结局在0、4、6和12个月时测量。
主要发现
以下为作者报告的结果。数字须连同人群和不确定性一起阅读。
- 112个月时,严格限制组比中度组多减体重(效应量-6.6 kg;95%置信区间-8.2至-5.1),全身脂肪量也减少更多(-5.5 kg;95%置信区间-7.1至-3.9)。
- 2严格组丢失的全身瘦体重(-1.2 kg;95%置信区间-2.0至-0.4)和大腿肌肉面积(-4.2 cm2;95%置信区间-6.5至-1.9)更多,但这些丢失与总体减重成比例,两组握力无差异。
- 3严格组的全髋骨密度下降更多(-0.017 g/cm2;95%置信区间-0.029至-0.005)。
- 4严格组的腹部皮下脂肪(-1890 cm3;95%置信区间-2560至-1219)和内脏脂肪(-1389 cm3;95%置信区间-1748至-1030)也减少更多。作者概括为减重和减脂幅度约为2倍。
局限与不确定性
- 1仅纳入一个城市中45至65岁、肥胖且缺乏有组织运动的女性,结果可能不适用于男性、更年轻的女性或运动量很大的人。
- 2运动为鼓励而非监督,蛋白质摄入为规定量,摘要未说明是否监测,这些都可能影响瘦体重的结果。
- 3主要结局是瘦体重,骨密度、力量和脂肪结果属于次要结局,确定性较低。
- 4以上解读仅基于摘要。
对日常健康的启示
通过严格节食快速减重,并没有成比例地多损失肌肉或握力,但髋部骨密度损失更多。这是需要谨慎的理由,尤其是骨量减少或骨质疏松的女性,在采用极低能量饮食前应先与医生讨论。这项研究并不说明哪种饮食整体更好。
如何联系自己的数据
请在每天同一时间、用同一台体重秤称重,观察每周趋势。家用体脂秤给出的体脂率只是估算值,不要把小幅变化当作肌肉或脂肪的真实变化。骨密度无法在家追踪,需要到医院做检查。
如何理解这类证据
随机分组有助于因果推断,仍须检查分配、盲法、失访、随访时间和具体对照;标为随机试验不自动意味着高确定性。
作者的结构化摘要 English
以下英文摘要按记录的开放许可转载,属于作者原始材料,不是 MoveVitals 的解读。上方已提供研究解读,分别说明作者结果与本站解释;重要结论可直接核对原文。
Importance
Severely energy-restricted diets are the most effective dietary obesity treatment. However, there are concerns regarding potential adverse effects on body composition.
Objective
To compare the long-term effects of weight loss via severe vs moderate energy restriction on lean mass and other aspects of body composition.
Design, setting, and participants
The Type of Energy Manipulation for Promoting Optimum Metabolic Health and Body Composition in Obesity (TEMPO) Diet Trial was a 12-month, single-center, randomized clinical trial. A total of 101 postmenopausal women, aged 45 to 65 years with body mass index (calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared) from 30 to 40, who were at least 5 years after menopause, had fewer than 3 hours of structured physical activity per week, and lived in the Sydney metropolitan area of New South Wales, Australia, were recruited between March 2013 and July 2016. Data analysis was conducted between October 2018 and August 2019.
Intervention
Participants were randomized to either 12 months of moderate (25%-35%) energy restriction with a food-based diet (moderate intervention) or 4 months of severe (65%-75%) energy restriction with a total meal replacement diet followed by moderate energy restriction for an additional 8 months (severe intervention). Both interventions had a prescribed protein intake of 1.0 g/kg of actual body weight per day, and physical activity was encouraged but not supervised.
Main outcomes and measures
The primary outcome was whole-body lean mass at 12 months after commencement of intervention. Secondary outcomes were body weight, thigh muscle area and muscle function (strength), bone mineral density, and fat mass and distribution, measured at 0, 4, 6, and 12 months.
Results
A total of 101 postmenopausal women were recruited (mean [SD] age, 58.0 [4.2] years; mean [SD] weight, 90.8 [9.1] kg; mean [SD] body mass index, 34.4 [2.5]). Compared with the moderate group at 12 months, the severe group lost more weight (effect size, -6.6 kg; 95% CI, -8.2 to -5.1 kg), lost more whole-body lean mass (effect size, -1.2 kg; 95% CI, -2.0 to -0.4 kg), and lost more thigh muscle area (effect size, -4.2 cm2; 95% CI, -6.5 to -1.9 cm2). However, decreases in whole-body lean mass and thigh muscle area were proportional to total weight loss, and there was no difference in muscle (handgrip) strength between groups. Total hip bone mineral density (effect size, -0.017 g/cm2; 95% CI, -0.029 to -0.005 g/cm2), whole-body fat mass (effect size, -5.5 kg; 95% CI, -7.1 to -3.9 kg), abdominal subcutaneous adipose tissue (effect size, -1890 cm3; 95% CI, -2560 to -1219 cm3), and visceral adipose tissue (effect size, -1389 cm3; 95% CI, -1748 to -1030 cm3) loss were also greater for the severe group than for the moderate group at 12 months.
Conclusions and relevance
Severe energy restriction had no greater adverse effect on relative whole-body lean mass or handgrip strength compared with moderate energy restriction and was associated with 2-fold greater weight and fat loss over 12 months. However, there was significantly greater loss of total hip bone mineral density with severe vs moderate energy restriction. Therefore, caution is necessary when implementing severe energy restriction in postmenopausal women, particularly those with osteopenia or osteoporosis.
Trial registration
anzctr.org.au Identifier: 12612000651886.
来源与署名
Effect of Weight Loss via Severe vs Moderate Energy Restriction on Lean Mass and Body Composition Among Postmenopausal Women With Obesity: The TEMPO Diet Randomized Clinical Trial.
Seimon RV, Wild-Taylor AL, Keating SE, McClintock S, Harper C, Gibson AA, Johnson NA, Fernando HA, Markovic TP, Center JR, Franklin J, Liu PY, Grieve SM, Lagopoulos J, Caterson ID, Byrne NM, Sainsbury A.
JAMA network open · 2019-10-02
DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.13733 ↗PubMed · 31664441 ↗Europe PMC · 记录的开放许可: cc by ↗摘要版权归原作者,依据来源记录的开放许可转载。中文译文辅助阅读,英文摘要用于核对术语与具体数值;本站的方法学解释与作者结论分别呈现。
MoveVitals 编辑解读 · 健康教育内容 · 未记录个人临床审阅
来源核验日期 2026-11-01
实用健康指南
放在一起读
更早的进食窗口与更大的体重和胰岛素获益相关,优于晚间进食
汇总41项随机对照试验(2287名参与者,干预时间中位数8周)发现,限时进食比日常饮食体重低2.15 kg(95%置信区间−2.56至−1.74),而早吃比晚吃体重多降1.15 kg(95%置信区间−1.86至−0.45)。多数试验较短,只有6个研究组检验了早间进食,结局是身体和血液指标,不是心脏病发作或死亡。
BMJ Medicine
限热量饮食再加上午8点至下午4点进食窗口,1年减重无明显额外优势
139名肥胖患者都按限制热量的饮食进食,其中一组再加上上午8:00至下午4:00的进食窗口,12个月平均体重变化为−8.0 kg,单纯限热量组为−6.3 kg。净差值−1.8 kg(95%置信区间−4.0至0.4;P=0.11)无统计学意义,该区间既不能排除窗口确有获益,也不能排除毫无作用。
The New England Journal of Medicine
20人住院试验:超加工饮食让人每天多摄入508 kcal并增重
20名成年人在医院研究病房住了28天,两种菜单各吃2周、想吃多少吃多少:超加工菜单让他们每天多摄入508 kcal(±106,标准误,P=0.0001),体重增加0.9 kg;未加工菜单则让体重减轻0.9 kg。样本小、周期短、食物全程由研究方提供,既不能说明日常生活中的长期结果,也无法确定是食物的哪种特点导致多吃。
Cell Metabolism
地中海饮食加橄榄油或坚果与心血管事件减少相关(更正后的试验)
在7447名55至80岁、心血管风险较高的西班牙成年人中,被分到加特级初榨橄榄油(风险比0.69,95%置信区间0.53至0.91)或加坚果(风险比0.72,0.54至0.95)的地中海饮食组,发生主要心血管事件的风险低于被告知减少脂肪的对照组。试验存在随机化失误,2013年的报告已撤回并重新估算,证据有力但并不完美。
The New England Journal of Medicine

