Saltar al contenido
Salud mental y cogniciónEnsayo aleatorizado3 min read

Three exercise types in inactive older adults: no significant Stroop difference between groups

Colectivo editorial MoveVitals · Study published · Reading updated

Original paper:The effect of three different exercise training modalities on cognitive and physical function in a healthy older population. · European review of aging and physical activity : official journal of the European Group for Research into Elderly and Physical Activity · 2017 · Artículo original ↗

Idea principal

In 67 inactive adults aged 55 to 75, there was no significant group-by-time difference in Stroop reaction time after 16 weeks of resistance, high-intensity interval or moderate continuous training (P > .05). The authors' rankings rest on effect sizes in very small groups of 13 to 22 people, so they should be read as hints, not firm differences.

Study design

Ensayo aleatorizado

Reading basis

Published abstract

Reading focus

Comparator & uncertainty

Esta explicación editorial está disponible en inglés, chino simplificado y chino tradicional. Esta interfaz muestra la lectura en inglés.

Pregunta de investigación

Exercise is thought to protect thinking and physical function in later life, but studies comparing aerobic and resistance training are few and inconsistent. High-intensity interval training raises fitness even in older adults, yet its effect on cognition had not been tested. The authors compared three exercise types against a control group.

Población y método

Randomised trial of 67 inactive adults aged 55 to 75, assigned to resistance training (n = 22), high-intensity aerobic interval training (n = 13), moderate continuous aerobic training (n = 13) or a control group (n = 19) for 16 weeks. Cognition was measured with a Stroop task (reaction time) and physical function with the Timed-Up-and-Go test and a submaximal Bruce treadmill test. The abstract does not describe the training programs in detail or report dropouts.

Resultados

The authors’ reported results. Read each estimate with its population and uncertainty.

  1. 1
    There was no significant GROUP x TIME interaction for Stroop reaction time (P > .05), meaning the groups did not differ significantly in how their times changed.
  2. 2
    By effect size, the interval training group improved most on the simple Stroop neutral task (ES = 1.11).
  3. 3
    The moderate continuous training group had very large effect-size improvements on the executive tasks, Stroop incongruent (ES = 1.28) and interference (ES = 1.31).
  4. 4
    Interval training had the largest effect-size gains in physical function: walking endurance (ES = 0.91) and functional mobility (ES = 0.36).

Límites e incertidumbre

  1. 1
    The groups were small (13 to 22 people), so effect sizes are unstable, and the abstract reports no confidence intervals.
  2. 2
    The significance test was null, so the authors' claim that moderate continuous and resistance training were superior for executive function rests on effect sizes, not statistical proof.
  3. 3
    Participants were healthy, inactive volunteers aged 55 to 75, so the results may not apply to people with health problems or those who already exercise.
  4. 4
    This reading is based on the abstract only, which does not give the control group's changes or dropouts.

Relevancia práctica

Over 16 weeks, no exercise type clearly beat the others on a thinking-speed test in this small trial, though interval training looked best for walking endurance and mobility in effect-size terms. It is not strong evidence for choosing one style over another. A mix of what you will actually keep doing is a sensible approach, with your own clinician's input if you have health conditions.

Tus datos

You can track what this trial measured physically: walking endurance and mobility can be followed by timed walks, VO2max estimates and heart rate at a fixed pace. Use the same device, route and time of day, and look at changes over weeks. The Stroop reaction time is a lab task, not something a wearable records.

Cómo interpretar la evidencia

Randomisation can support causal inference, but check allocation, blinding, missing outcomes, follow-up and the actual comparator. A trial label alone does not establish high certainty.

Resumen estructurado de los autores English

El resumen original en inglés se reproduce con atribución bajo la licencia indicada. Es una fuente, no una interpretación de MoveVitals. El análisis preparado figura arriba; verifica los resultados importantes en la fuente.

Background

Older adults are encouraged to participate in regular physical activity to counter the age-related declines in physical and cognitive health. Literature on the effect of different exercise training modalities (aerobic vs resistance) on these health-related outcomes is not only sparse, but results are inconsistent. In general, it is believed that exercise has a positive effect on executive cognitive function, possibly because of the physiological adaptations through increases in fitness. Indications are that high-intensity interval training is a potent stimulus to improve cardiovascular fitness, even in older adults; however, its effect on cognitive function has not been studied before. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to compare the effects of resistance training, high-intensity aerobic interval training and moderate continuous aerobic training on the cognitive and physical functioning of healthy older adults.

Methods

Sixty-seven inactive individuals (55 to 75 years) were randomly assigned to a resistance training (RT) group ( n = 22), high-intensity aerobic interval training (HIIT) group ( n = 13), moderate continuous aerobic training (MCT) group ( n = 13) and a control (CON) group ( n = 19) for a period of 16 weeks. Cognitive function was assessed with a Stroop task and physical function with the Timed-Up-and-Go (TUG) and submaximal Bruce treadmill tests.

Results

No significant GROUP x TIME interaction was found for Stroop reaction time ( P > .05). The HIIT group showed the greatest practical significant improvement in reaction time on the information processing task, i.e. Stroop Neutral (ES = 1.11). MCT group participants had very large practical significant improvements in reaction time on the executive cognitive tasks, i.e. Stroop Incongruent and Interference (ES = 1.28 and 1.31, respectively). The HIIT group showed the largest practically significant increase in measures of physical function, i.e. walking endurance (ES = 0.91) and functional mobility (ES = 0.36).

Conclusions

MCT and RT proved to be superior to HIIT for the enhancement of older individuals' executive cognitive function; whereas HIIT were most beneficial for improvement in information processing speed. HIIT also induced the largest gains in physical function.

Fuentes y atribución

The effect of three different exercise training modalities on cognitive and physical function in a healthy older population.

Coetsee C, Terblanche E.

European review of aging and physical activity : official journal of the European Group for Research into Elderly and Physical Activity · 2017-08-10

DOI: 10.1186/s11556-017-0183-5 ↗PubMed · 28811842 ↗Europe PMC · Licencia registrada: cc by ↗

Abstract © the original authors, reproduced under the recorded open licence. Translations support reading; use the English record to check terminology and numerical results. Our methodological interpretation is separate from the authors’ conclusions.

Interpretación editorial de MoveVitals · contenido educativo · sin revisión clínica individual registrada

Fuentes verificadas 2026-11-01

Guías prácticas

Leer en contexto

·Revisión de revisiones

Exercise gave small-to-moderate cognitive gains across 133 reviews of trials

An umbrella review of 133 systematic reviews (2724 trials, 258,279 participants) found that exercise improved general cognition (SMD 0.42, 95% CI 0.37 to 0.47), memory (0.26) and executive function (0.24), with the largest memory gains in children and adolescents and the largest executive function gains in people with ADHD. Most of the reviews (94) were rated critically low in quality and the effects were smaller in the best-rated ones (0.23 for general cognition), and the outcomes were test scores, not dementia.

British Journal of Sports Medicine

Explicaciones detalladasLeer estudio →
·Metaanálisis observacional

More daily steps linked to fewer depressive symptoms across 33 studies of adults

Pooling 33 observational studies of 96,173 adults, higher daily step counts went with fewer depressive symptoms, and in the two prospective cohorts that could be pooled, 7000 or more steps a day went with a lower risk of depression than fewer (RR 0.69, 95% CI 0.62-0.77). Most studies were cross-sectional, so low mood may be reducing steps as much as steps affect mood, and the authors say the prediction intervals call for caution.

JAMA Network Open

Explicaciones detalladasLeer estudio →
·Metaanálisis de ensayos

Exercise eased depression in 218 trials, but confidence in the evidence is low

In a network meta-analysis of 218 trials with 14,170 people who met criteria for major depression, walking or jogging, yoga, strength training, mixed aerobic exercise and tai chi or qigong each gave moderate reductions in depression compared with active controls (walking or jogging: Hedges' g −0.62, 95% credible interval −0.80 to −0.45). Confidence in the evidence was low for walking or jogging and very low for the other treatments, mainly because only one study met the low-risk-of-bias criteria.

BMJ

Explicaciones detalladasLeer estudio →
·Revisión de revisiones

Physical activity eased depression and anxiety across 97 reviews of trials

Across 97 systematic reviews that pooled 1039 randomized trials with 128,119 participants, physical activity had medium effects on depression (median effect size −0.43) and anxiety (−0.42) compared with usual care, and higher-intensity activity went with larger gains. Most of those reviews (77) were rated critically low in quality, and the evidence mainly concerns mild-to-moderate symptoms.

British Journal of Sports Medicine

Explicaciones detalladasLeer estudio →
Salud mental y cognición →